For speech-language pathologists

What is traditional articulation therapy, and when does it fit?

Published · Updated

The short answer

Traditional articulation therapy, associated with Charles Van Riper, teaches one sound at a time. The child first learns to identify the target and tell it apart from their error, then learns to produce it, often with placement and shaping cues, and builds it up through syllables, words, sentences and conversation. It suits motor-based errors such as distorted /s/ or /r/. For pattern-based phonological errors, a small randomized trial found a phonological approach generalized better, and published support for the traditional approach is mostly clinical description.

What “traditional” means

There’s no single definition. Caroline Bowen traces the procedures to the “stimulus methods” that Travis described in 1931 and Powers in 1971, and to Van Riper (Bowen). Van Riper (1978) described the hallmark of traditional therapy as a sequence: identify the standard sound, discriminate it from the error by scanning and comparing, vary and correct productions until the sound is right, then strengthen and stabilize it in all contexts and speaking situations (Van Riper, 1978, quoted by Bowen).

The clinician acts as teacher, taking the child through carefully graded steps, usually one phoneme at a time, from ear training to spontaneous conversation and self-monitoring (Bowen). It’s still common: in a US survey of SLPs working with 3- to 6-year-olds, more reported using traditional intervention than any other type, though many also used parts of phonological approaches (Brumbaugh & Smit, 2013).

The stages, step by step

Stages of traditional articulation therapy
StageWhat happens
Sensory-perceptual (ear) trainingThe child learns to identify and name the target sound and discriminate it from other sounds, first in isolation and then in more complex contexts (Bowen). ASHA describes perception tasks such as judging correct and incorrect versions of a word, moving from others’ speech to the child’s own (ASHA).
EstablishmentEliciting the target sound and stabilizing it at a voluntary level (ASHA), often in isolation or syllables, using the cues below.
StabilizationVan Riper’s final step: strengthening the sound until it holds in every context (Van Riper, 1978), usually by practicing it in syllables, words, phrases and sentences.
Generalization (transfer)Carryover at increasingly challenging levels, up to conversation (ASHA).
MaintenanceMaking the sound automatic, with self-monitoring and self-correction (ASHA).

For the levels and when to move up, see the articulation hierarchy; for the last stages, see improving carryover.

Placement and shaping cues

Once the child can produce the sound, the same tutorial recommends blocked practice (the same target many times in a row) early on, then more varied practice, and reducing feedback from 90–100% of trials to 40–50% as skills develop (Preston et al., 2020). See feedback frequency and motor learning.

What the evidence says

Traditional or phonological: when each fits

ASHA describes articulation disorders as difficulties with the motor production of speech sounds and phonological disorders as difficulties with the linguistic side. It also notes they’re often hard to tell apart, that one child can show both, and that different errors may need different approaches. Treatment choice depends on the child’s age, the type of errors, severity and the effect on intelligibility (ASHA).

Matching approach to error profile
Error profileApproach that may fit
A few sounds in error, especially distortions (for example a lateral /s/ or a distorted /r/)Traditional or other motor-based treatment, which focuses on eliciting a correct-sounding production (Preston et al., 2020)
Substitutions or deletions that follow a pattern (fronting, stopping, final consonant deletion)A phonological contrast approach such as minimal pairs or maximal or multiple oppositions (ASHA; Storkel, 2022)
Highly unintelligible speech with extensive omissions and few consonantsThe cycles approach (ASHA)
Inconsistent productions of the same wordA core vocabulary approach, typically before contrast work (ASHA)

Contrast approaches are aimed at substitution and deletion patterns rather than distortions (Storkel, 2022). See minimal pairs therapy, the cycles approach, and, if childhood apraxia of speech is suspected, DTTC and apraxia vs speech sound disorder.

Questions SLPs ask

What are the steps of traditional articulation therapy?

Ear training to identify and discriminate the sound, then establishing it (often in isolation or syllables), then stabilizing it in syllables, words, phrases and sentences, carrying it into conversation, and maintaining it with self-monitoring.

Is traditional articulation therapy evidence-based?

Its support is mostly older clinical description, though modern motor-based treatment built on similar principles has trial evidence for residual /r/ errors. For pattern-based errors, a small RCT favoured a phonological approach.

What is the difference between articulation and phonological therapy?

Articulation therapy teaches how to make a sound; phonological therapy teaches how sounds contrast to change meaning, usually with word pairs. ASHA notes that one child can show both kinds of error.

Should I use oral motor exercises before teaching a sound?

A Cochrane review found no strong evidence that non-speech oral motor exercises help children with speech sound disorders, on their own or added to speech therapy.

Sources

Join the Early Adopter Program