For speech-language pathologists

What is the cycles approach, and does it work?

Published · Updated

The short answer

The cycles approach, developed by Hodson and Paden, is a phonological treatment for children with highly unintelligible speech. It targets error patterns rather than single sounds, works on each pattern for a set time and then moves on, and recycles patterns until they appear in spontaneous speech, with focused auditory input (auditory bombardment) in every session. The evidence is promising but limited: mostly small studies, with reviews rating it suggestive, and no completed Cochrane review comparing phonological approaches.

What the cycles approach is

ASHA describes the cycles approach as combining target selection with a treatment schedule. It targets phonological pattern errors and is designed for children with highly unintelligible speech who have extensive omissions, some substitutions and a restricted use of consonants (ASHA).

Treatment runs in cycles of 5 to 16 weeks. One or more patterns are targeted in each cycle, then a new cycle targets different patterns, and patterns are recycled until they appear in the child’s spontaneous speech. There’s no set mastery criterion within a cycle: cycles aim to stimulate the emergence of a sound or pattern, not to produce mastery, approximating the gradual way typical phonology develops. ASHA notes that cycles can be used with multilingual learners (ASHA).

Rudolph and Wendt (2014), summarizing Hodson, describe three components that Hodson considers essential: pattern-focused selection of targets, cyclical targeting of problem patterns, and focused auditory input combined with production practice.

How a cycle runs

Elements of the cycles approach, from published summaries
ElementWhat it involves
Choosing patternsConsistent patterns occurring 40% of the time or more, with stimulable targets (Bowen). Rudolph & Wendt also weighed developmental appropriateness (primary vs secondary patterns) and the effect on intelligibility, and chose at least two sounds per pattern (Rudolph & Wendt, 2014).
Primary patternsTargeted first: early syllable structure patterns, anterior–posterior contrasts and /s/ clusters (Bowen).
Time, not masteryEach phoneme within a pattern is targeted for about 1 hour (sometimes 2), and the first cycle lasts 6 to 18 hours (Bowen). New patterns are introduced before old ones are fully learned (Rudolph & Wendt, 2014).
Auditory bombardmentFocused listening to 15 to 20 words, amplified, at the start and end of each session, plus once a day at home without amplification (Bowen). ASHA notes auditory bombardment is used with cycles at the beginning and end of sessions (ASHA).
Production practiceDrill-play with four or five picture-word cards, with activities changed every 7 to 8 minutes (Bowen).
Home programDaily listening at home (Bowen); Rudolph & Wendt sent homework at the end of each week (Rudolph & Wendt, 2014).

For children with extremely disordered phonological systems, the summary on Caroline Bowen’s site says 3 or 4 cycles, about 30 to 40 hours in all, are typically needed to become intelligible (Bowen). That’s a clinical estimate rather than a trial result. For which patterns are typical at which ages, see phonological processes by age.

What the evidence says

Rudolph and Wendt list their own limitations: a small sample, probes given by the treating clinician (so not blind), a schedule more intense than typical practice, and single-word measures (Rudolph & Wendt, 2014). Across the field, a review of 26 studies of preschool speech sound interventions found that most represented lower-graded evidence (Wren et al., 2018).

How it compares with other phonological approaches

There’s little head-to-head evidence. A 2003 Cochrane review found speech and language therapy effective for children with phonological difficulties compared with controls (standardized mean difference 0.44, 95% CI 0.01 to 0.86) (Law et al., 2003). An updated Cochrane review was published only as a protocol in 2017 (Law et al., 2017), and we didn’t find a completed Cochrane review that compares phonological approaches with each other. A review classifying preschool interventions found the highest-graded evidence for three studies in its auditory-perceptual and integrated categories (Wren et al., 2018).

ASHA’s Practice Portal describes who each approach may suit (ASHA):

Phonological approaches and who ASHA says they may suit
ApproachWhat ASHA says
CyclesDesigned for children with highly unintelligible speech, extensive omissions and restricted consonant use
Minimal oppositions (minimal pairs)Children with a few speech errors may benefit most
Maximal oppositionsMay help children with several errors across different sound classes
Multiple oppositionsTargets phoneme collapse, where one sound replaces many others

In a US survey of SLPs working with 3- to 6-year-olds, more reported using traditional intervention than other types, though many used aspects of phonological interventions (Brumbaugh & Smit, 2013).

Who it suits, and its limitations

Measuring progress in cycles

Because cycles don’t use mastery criteria, progress has to be shown on untreated material. Rudolph and Wendt used a 27-word generalization probe, percent consonants correct and the percentage of occurrence of each pattern, plus a parent rating of the treatment (Rudolph & Wendt, 2014). Recycling decisions rest on whether patterns are appearing in spontaneous speech (ASHA).

Questions SLPs ask

How long is a cycle in the cycles approach?

ASHA describes cycles of 5 to 16 weeks. Within a cycle, each phoneme in a pattern is typically targeted for about an hour before moving on.

Is the cycles approach evidence-based?

There is supportive evidence from small studies and one partly cycles-based RCT, and a 2010 review rated it suggestive. Larger controlled trials are still needed.

Is auditory bombardment necessary?

It’s a core part of Hodson’s approach, but one 2026 study of three preschoolers found adding auditory stimulation didn’t improve or speed up gains. That’s a very small sample, so it isn’t settled.

Cycles or minimal pairs?

ASHA describes cycles for highly unintelligible children and minimal pairs for children with a few errors. Few studies compare them directly.

Can the cycles approach be used with bilingual children?

ASHA notes that cycles can be used with multilingual learners. Assess in all of a child’s languages first so transfer patterns aren’t treated as errors.

Sources

Join the Early Adopter Program