For speech-language pathologists
What is stimulability, and why does it matter in speech therapy?
Published · Updated
The short answer
Stimulability is a child’s ability to say a sound correctly when copying a model, even though they usually get it wrong. Speech-language pathologists (SLPs) test it by having the child imitate the sound alone, in syllables and in words, often with cues. Stimulable sounds are more likely to improve without direct treatment; sounds that aren’t stimulable usually need teaching. For families, a practical rule follows: start practicing a sound at home once your child can make it with cues.
What stimulability means
ASHA defines stimulability as a child’s ability to accurately imitate a model of a speech sound that the child currently says incorrectly (ASHA). Researchers describe it as a general measure of a child’s ability to correct errors when imitating (McAllister et al., 2022).
A child who says “tea” for “key” might still manage a clear “k” when they watch and copy the SLP. That sound is stimulable. If they can’t produce it even with a model and help, it’s nonstimulable. ASHA says stimulability testing helps show how well a child imitates the sound in different contexts, whether the sound is likely to be acquired without intervention, and which targets suit therapy (ASHA).
Stimulability isn’t fixed. In a study comparing children with typical and disordered speech, the stimulable sounds changed most over time, and the authors suggest that being stimulable may signal that a sound is on its way in naturally (Miccio, Elbert & Forrest, 1999).
How SLPs test it
There are few standardized procedures for testing stimulability, although some test batteries include stimulability subtests (ASHA). The GFTA-3, for example, has a stimulability section (Pearson). In practice the SLP models the sound and asks the child to copy it at one or more levels: on its own, in a syllable, in a word or in a phrase (ASHA).
- A simple criterion. One common definition counts a sound as stimulable if the child gets at least 3 of 10 imitated attempts right (Storkel, 2022).
- Graded support. Dynamic versions record how much help a child needs. The Scaffolding Scale of Stimulability uses a 21-point hierarchy of cues and changes to the speaking task (Glaspey & Stoel-Gammon, 2007), and a later dynamic assessment of speech adaptability uses a 15-point scale (Glaspey, 2012). See dynamic assessment.
- Free probes. Storkel’s complexity tutorial provides free resources for testing the accuracy and stimulability of single consonants and clusters (Storkel, 2018).
What makes a sound easier to copy? In one study, stimulability was related to how visible the sound is, the child’s age, family socioeconomic status and the child’s general imitation skills, but not to speech perception, severity, ear infection history, language ability, consistency of errors, the amount of stimulation given or willingness to self-correct (Lof, 1996). Stimulability also tracks the wider speech system: in 18 children aged 3;6 to 5;5, it was strongly related to percentage of consonants correct and to the number of sounds in the child’s inventory (Tyler & Macrae, 2010).
What it predicts
- Change without direct treatment. Six preschoolers aged 4;11 to 5;6 were each taught two sounds missing from their inventory. For 86% of the 28 sounds monitored, change followed pretreatment stimulability: stimulable sounds tended to improve whichever sound was being treated, while nonstimulable sounds seemed to need direct treatment (Powell, Elbert & Dinnsen, 1991).
- Natural acquisition. In eight children (four with phonological disorders aged 3;10 to 5;7 and four typically developing aged 3;6 to 4;1), stimulable sounds changed most, and nonstimulable sounds were least likely to change without treatment (Miccio, Elbert & Forrest, 1999).
- Who resolves without therapy. In a Cantonese-speaking cohort, 43 preschoolers with speech sound disorders who didn’t receive therapy were followed for up to 2 years. Children who were stimulable for all their errors, and those rated more intelligible by caregivers, were more likely to resolve and did so sooner. The authors suggest prioritizing children with low intelligibility and poor stimulability for services (To et al., 2022).
- Response to treatment in older children. In 33 young people aged 9 to 15 with residual /ɹ/ errors, a “low stimulability” group barely responded to a week of traditional treatment but responded strongly to ultrasound biofeedback, while a “high stimulability” group gained in both phases (McAllister et al., 2022). See biofeedback for the R sound.
These are small studies, and older findings weren’t unanimous: McAllister and colleagues cite one 1967 study as a contrary finding. Their review sums up the general finding as higher stimulability going with greater gains without treatment (McAllister et al., 2022, citing Powell & Miccio, 1996, and To et al., 2022). Stimulability is a clue, not a guarantee. For whether a child needs therapy at all, see does my child need speech therapy?
Treat stimulable or nonstimulable sounds first?
Approaches disagree, and both sides have evidence.
- Start with stimulable sounds. In a trial of 48 children with moderate or severe phonological delays, those treated on early-developing sounds they partly knew made more progress on the treated sounds than those treated on late-developing sounds they knew little about. Generalization didn’t differ between groups, and parents were more satisfied with the first approach (Rvachew & Nowak, 2001). Summarizing three randomized trials, Rvachew reported generally better outcomes when stimulable targets were treated (Rvachew, 2005).
- Start with nonstimulable sounds. The complexity approach counts the least stimulable sounds as the most complex and treats them first, aiming for wider, cascading generalization (ASHA; Storkel, 2018). The reasoning follows from the Powell study: if stimulable sounds improve anyway, treating nonstimulable ones may produce the most change overall (Powell, Elbert & Dinnsen, 1991).
- Make the sound stimulable first. Miccio and Elbert describe a treatment program that “teaches” stimulability to young children with very small sound inventories, because nonstimulable sounds can be hard to teach to these children (Miccio & Elbert, 1996).
- Add listening work. In one study, sounds that weren’t stimulable before group cycles treatment showed no progress. When each child first had three brief individual sessions working on stimulability through phonetic placement and on perception of the target sounds, most targets progressed, including nonstimulable ones (Rvachew, Rafaat & Martin, 1999). Rvachew’s summary of three randomized trials likewise found perception training alongside phonetic placement improved outcomes for nonstimulable targets (Rvachew, 2005).
For how SLPs weigh this against development, intelligibility and family priorities, see which sound to treat first.
What it means for home practice
Stimulability gives families a practical rule: practice saying a sound at home once your child can make it with cues, at the level your SLP sets. An NHS parent booklet describes it this way: the SLP first shows the child how to make the sound, and once the child can say it, families practice it through games. The SLP says where to start, and families can drop back to an easier stage to help the child succeed (Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust).
Research programs work the same way. A motor-based tutorial starts structured practice once a child is correct at least some of the time in syllables, after a “prepractice” stage of modeling, cueing and shaping (Preston et al., 2020). A contrast therapy tutorial establishes the sound in isolation or syllables first if the child can’t yet produce it, and starts with imitation if the child can produce it with cues (Storkel, 2022).
- Before your child can make the sound: listening games, such as hearing the difference between the new sound and the one they use, and simply saying words clearly for them to hear. The same booklet advises modeling the word back rather than insisting on a correct repeat (Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust).
- Once they can make it with cues: short practice using the same cue your SLP uses, at the sound, syllable or word level they’re working on.
- Once they can make it without cues: words, then phrases and sentences, as your SLP moves them up. See the articulation hierarchy.
Ask your child’s SLP which stage they’re at and what cue works. For more, see speech practice at home, short daily speech practice and should I correct my child’s speech?
Questions SLPs ask
What does stimulable mean in speech therapy?
A sound is stimulable if a child can say it correctly when copying a model, even though they usually say it wrong. A sound the child can’t produce even with a model and help is nonstimulable.
How is stimulability tested?
The SLP models the sound and asks the child to copy it on its own, in syllables and in words, sometimes with extra cues. One common criterion counts a sound as stimulable at 3 or more correct out of 10 tries.
If a sound is stimulable, will my child outgrow the error?
It’s more likely, not certain. In small studies stimulable sounds tended to improve without direct treatment, but an SLP also weighs age, intelligibility and the child’s other errors.
Should we practice a sound at home before my child can say it?
Usually not as a speaking drill. Listening games and hearing you say the words clearly can help, and saying practice starts once your child can make the sound with cues. Ask your SLP which stage your child is at.
What happens if a sound isn’t stimulable?
The SLP may teach the sound directly with placement and shaping cues, work on stimulability and listening first, or, for older children with persistent R errors, consider biofeedback. Some approaches deliberately choose nonstimulable sounds as targets.
Sources
- ASHA Practice Portal: Speech sound disorders (articulation and phonology).
- McAllister, T., Eads, A., Kabakoff, H., Scott, M., Boyce, S., Whalen, D. H., & Preston, J. L. (2022). Baseline stimulability predicts patterns of response to traditional and ultrasound biofeedback treatment for residual speech sound disorder. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 65(8), 2860–2880.
- Miccio, A. W., Elbert, M., & Forrest, K. (1999). The relationship between stimulability and phonological acquisition in children with normally developing and disordered phonologies. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 8(4), 347–363.
- Pearson Assessments: Goldman-Fristoe Test of Articulation 3 (GFTA-3), by R. Goldman and M. Fristoe. Product page and FAQs.
- Storkel, H. L. (2022). Minimal, maximal, or multiple: Which contrastive intervention approach to use with children with speech sound disorders? Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 53(3), 632–645.
- Glaspey, A. M., & Stoel-Gammon, C. (2007). A dynamic approach to phonological assessment. Advances in Speech-Language Pathology, 9(4), 286–296.
- Glaspey, A. M. (2012). Stimulability measures and dynamic assessment of speech adaptability. Perspectives on Language Learning and Education, 19(1), 12–18.
- Storkel, H. L. (2018). The complexity approach to phonological treatment: How to select treatment targets. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 49(3), 463–481.
- Lof, G. L. (1996). Factors associated with speech-sound stimulability. Journal of Communication Disorders, 29(4), 255–278.
- Tyler, A. A., & Macrae, T. (2010). Stimulability: Relationships to other characteristics of children’s phonological systems. Clinical Linguistics & Phonetics, 24(4–5), 300–310.
- Powell, T. W., Elbert, M., & Dinnsen, D. A. (1991). Stimulability as a factor in the phonological generalization of misarticulating preschool children. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 34(6), 1318–1328.
- To, C. K. S., McLeod, S., Sam, K. L., & Law, T. (2022). Predicting which children will normalize without intervention for speech sound disorders. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 65(5), 1724–1741.
- Powell, T. W., & Miccio, A. W. (1996). Stimulability: A useful clinical tool. Journal of Communication Disorders, 29(4), 237–253.
- Rvachew, S., & Nowak, M. (2001). The effect of target-selection strategy on phonological learning. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 44(3), 610–623.
- Rvachew, S. (2005). Stimulability and treatment success. Topics in Language Disorders, 25(3), 207–219.
- Miccio, A. W., & Elbert, M. (1996). Enhancing stimulability: A treatment program. Journal of Communication Disorders, 29(4), 335–351.
- Rvachew, S., Rafaat, S., & Martin, M. (1999). Stimulability, speech perception skills, and the treatment of phonological disorders. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 8(1), 33–43.
- Oxford Health NHS Foundation Trust, Speech and Language Therapy: Introducing a new sound (parent booklet).
- Preston, J. L., Benway, N. R., Leece, M. C., Hitchcock, E. R., & McAllister, T. (2020). Tutorial: Motor-based treatment strategies for /r/ distortions. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 51(4), 966–980.