Parent question
Should I correct my child’s speech?
Published · Updated
The short answer
Usually it works better to model the word than to say “No, say it like this.” Child speech services suggest repeating the word back the right way as part of your normal reply, then carrying on: if your child says “a big tat,” you say “A big cat! What’s the cat doing?” Your child doesn’t have to copy you. During practice time, your speech-language pathologist (SLP) may ask you to give more direct feedback. Stuttering is different: don’t correct it, and listen to what your child says, not how.
Model it instead: recasting
SLPs call this recasting or modeling: you repeat what your child said, using the correct sounds, words or grammar. An Australian public child health service describes it as repeating the correct word back to your child during natural conversation, best done around whatever your child is interested in at the time. The child doesn’t have to repeat your model; it’s important for them simply to hear it. Use a natural speaking speed, and repeat and rephrase more than you would with an adult. Over-exaggerated models are listed as unhelpful (Gold Coast Health).
Most of the research on recasts is about grammar rather than speech sounds. A 2015 review of 35 studies, with a meta-analysis of 14, found the evidence limited and of varying quality, but supportive of recasts for children with language difficulties (Cleave et al., 2015).
| Your child says | Instead of | Try |
|---|---|---|
| “Look, a wabbit!” | “No, say rabbit.” | “A rabbit! The rabbit’s eating.” |
| “I want the tup.” | “It’s cup, not tup.” | “The blue cup? Here’s your cup.” |
| “The thun’s out.” | “Put your tongue in!” | “The sun’s out. It’s a sunny day.” |
| “Me goed to the park.” | “Say ‘I went’.” | “You went to the park! Who went with you?” |
Praise the effort
When your child tries a hard sound, notice the trying: “You worked hard on that S,” or “I like how you had another go.” In a set of six studies of fifth graders working on puzzles, children praised for effort kept going longer and enjoyed the task more after a failure than children praised for being clever (Mueller & Dweck, 1998). Those studies weren’t about speech, but effort is the part your child controls.
For more on keeping practice enjoyable, see motivating your child to do speech homework.
Practice time vs everyday talk
There are two different situations, and your child’s speech-language pathologist (SLP) may want you to respond differently in each.
- Short practice times. When you sit down for a few minutes with the words your SLP picked, your child is focused on the sound, so direct feedback can fit: telling them which tries were right, or using a cue the SLP showed you. Ask how often to give feedback. See feedback frequency in speech practice.
- Everyday talk. At dinner, in the car or at the park, your child is thinking about what to say, not how. Recast and move on. The same health service says you don’t need to recast constantly throughout the day (Gold Coast Health).
Once your child can say a sound well in practice, the SLP may suggest a gentle reminder for everyday talk. Agree it together first. See why my child can say a sound in therapy but not at home.
Why constant correction can backfire
We couldn’t find a study that tests what happens when parents correct every speech-sound error, so this rests on guidance from programs and services rather than trials. That guidance points the same way:
- The Australian health service says you don’t need to recast all day, and that children don’t need to repeat after you (Gold Coast Health).
- The Lidcombe Program, a parent-delivered stuttering treatment, says comments on a child’s speech must be a positive experience and “must not be constant, intensive, or invasive,” and that if a child reacts negatively to being asked to say something again, those requests should stop and be discussed with the clinician (Onslow et al., 2024).
- ASHA’s consumer affiliate lists drawing attention to the speech of a person who stutters, appearing impatient, and finishing their words among things that can increase stuttering (CHSA).
Older children may already feel self-conscious about how they sound. See if your child is teased about their speech.
Stuttering: different advice
For stuttering, don’t correct how your child talks. Instead, NIDCD suggests (NIDCD):
- Keep home relaxed, with plenty of chances to talk.
- Listen closely and focus on what your child is saying.
- Speak a little more slowly and calmly yourself.
- Wait for your child to say the word, and don’t finish their sentences.
- If your child brings up stuttering, talk about it openly and honestly.
ASHA’s consumer affiliate puts it simply: the main way to help is to focus on what a person says rather than how they say it (CHSA).
There is one exception, and it only applies with an SLP. In the Lidcombe Program, a clinician trains parents to comment on their child’s speech, mostly by praising smooth talking. Occasionally, parents ask the child to say a stuttered word again. The program isn’t designed for parents to use without a clinician (Onslow et al., 2024). If you’re unsure whether your child’s bumps are typical, see stuttering or normal disfluency.
Questions parents ask
Should I correct my child’s pronunciation?
Repeating the word back correctly in your reply usually works better than pointing out the mistake. Your child doesn’t need to copy you. If your child sees an SLP, ask what they’d like you to do.
Should I make my child repeat words correctly?
Not in everyday talk. Child speech services say it’s enough for your child to hear the correct model. During short practice times, your SLP may ask for repeated tries.
Is it bad to correct a child’s speech?
An occasional correction won’t hurt, but correcting all day can turn talking into a test. Recast in everyday talk, and save direct feedback for the short practice times your SLP sets up.
Should I correct my child’s stuttering?
No. NIDCD advises listening to what your child says, waiting for them to finish, and not completing their sentences. Structured treatments like the Lidcombe Program have parents comment on speech only after training by an SLP.
Sources
- Gold Coast Health (Queensland Health): General strategies to support your child’s speech development.
- Cleave, P. L., Becker, S. D., Curran, M. K., Owen Van Horne, A. J., & Fey, M. E. (2015). The efficacy of recasts in language intervention: A systematic review and meta-analysis. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 24(2), 237–255.
- Mueller, C. M., & Dweck, C. S. (1998). Praise for intelligence can undermine children’s motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 75(1), 33–52.
- Onslow, M., Webber, M., Harrison, E., Arnott, S., Bridgman, K., Carey, B., Sheedy, S., O’Brian, S., MacMillan, V., Lloyd, W., & Hearne, A. (2024). The Lidcombe Program treatment guide (Version 1.6). Lidcombe Program Trainers Consortium.
- Communication Health Support Association (ASHA’s consumer affiliate): Stuttering and cluttering.
- NIDCD (NIH): Stuttering.