Parent question
Did the CDC lower speech milestones?
Published · Updated
The short answer
Not in the CDC’s view, though some talking milestones did move later. In 2022 the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics rewrote the checklists so each milestone is something most children (75% or more) do by that age, rather than an average age, to discourage “wait and see”. “Says about 50 words” now appears at 30 months. The CDC says it hasn’t lowered standards, but ASHA worried the changes could slow referrals. If you’re concerned, don’t wait.
What changed in 2022
The CDC’s Learn the Signs. Act Early. program has offered free milestone checklists since 2004. The original milestones were adapted from a parenting book and were based mainly on clinical opinion rather than research data (Zubler et al., 2022). In February 2022 the CDC and the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) published revised checklists, chosen by a panel of 8 child development experts (Zubler et al., 2022; McNeilly, 2022). The main changes:
- 75% instead of average ages. Lists built on the median (50th percentile) age may encourage waiting, because half of children haven’t reached the skill yet. The new checklists use skills that at least 75% of children are expected to show by each age. The experts rejected 85 or 90% because that would leave too little room to screen children at risk (Zubler et al., 2022).
- Two new checklists, at 15 and 30 months. These were added so every recommended well-child visit from 2 months to 5 years has one (Zubler et al., 2022).
- Fewer, clearer milestones. The number of milestones fell by 26.4% and 40.9% were replaced. A third of the milestones that were kept moved to a different age, and 67.7% of those moved to an older age. Language lost 4 milestones (9.1%), far fewer than the cognitive and social-emotional areas (Zubler et al., 2022).
- Warning signs folded in. The old checklists had separate warning signs. Most became milestones (59 of 77), and a child who misses any milestone should be considered for screening (Zubler et al., 2022).
The talking milestones now on the CDC checklists
| Age | Most children (75% or more) can |
|---|---|
| 12 months | Wave “bye-bye”; call a parent “mama”, “dada” or another special name; understand “no” (CDC) |
| 15 months | Try to say one or two words besides “mama” or “dada”, like “ba” for ball; look at a familiar object when you name it (CDC) |
| 18 months | Try to say three or more words besides “mama” or “dada”; follow one-step directions without gestures (CDC) |
| 2 years | Say at least two words together, like “More milk”; point to things in a book when asked (CDC) |
| 30 months | Say about 50 words; say two or more words together with an action word, like “Doggie run” (CDC) |
| 3 years | Talk with you using at least two back-and-forth exchanges; ask “who”, “what”, “where” or “why” questions (CDC) |
“Says about 50 words” and “two words with an action word” were new milestones at 30 months in 2022 (Zubler et al., 2022). For the full picture to age 5, with ASHA’s age ranges alongside, see talking milestones by age.
Why SLPs objected
- They weren’t asked. ASHA, the professional body for speech-language pathologists (SLPs), wasn’t involved in the revision (ASHA, 2022). In February 2022 it told the CDC it was concerned about inconsistencies and urged the agency to use SLPs’ expertise. It said it supported identifying children earlier, but that milestones given to parents must be evidence-based (ASHA, 2022).
- Moving skills later could entrench “wait and see”. ASHA said its members already see children referred later than they should be, and worried that moving skills to older ages would make waiting more common (ASHA, 2022). An article by ASHA’s chief staff officer for speech-language pathology said the higher threshold could delay referrals (McNeilly, 2022).
- Different lists, different ages. ASHA’s own milestones put at least 50 words between 19 and 24 months (ASHA), and the AAP’s parent site lists saying about 50 to 100 words by age 2 (AAP). The CDC places about 50 words at 30 months.
- Language and culture. ASHA noted that language milestones aren’t universal across languages, so translated checklists may not fit every family, and that checklists may not match the path of neurodivergent children (ASHA, 2022).
- The evidence behind the word counts. A 2023 review of the CDC’s expressive vocabulary milestones found the supporting evidence was conflicting, misaligned or missing, and that the samples behind them weren’t representative of US children. The authors called for larger, culturally inclusive studies (Roberts et al., 2023).
After meeting the CDC and AAP in early 2022, ASHA said the checklists could be used alongside other clinical tools but that it remained concerned some changes would slow or hold back referrals to early intervention (ASHA, 2022). ASHA’s current milestones also show the ages by which at least 75% of American English–speaking children have each skill, but set them out as age ranges (ASHA).
What the CDC and AAP said
- The checklists aren’t tests. The CDC told ASHA they are communication tools to encourage developmental monitoring and conversations with doctors, not screening tools, standards or guidelines. It said it has not lowered the standards of early childhood development, and that the changes shouldn’t affect how children are evaluated or qualify for services (ASHA, 2022).
- Screening still matters. Developmental screening with validated tools is also recommended at 9, 18 and 30 months, with autism screening at 18 and 24 months. Two of the milestone authors wrote that a child missing any milestone should be considered for extra screening or referred for evaluation (Zubler & Whitaker, 2022).
- The authors’ own caveats. About 80% of the new milestones had supporting normative data. The authors wrote that the checklists haven’t been tested to see whether they lead to appropriate screening and earlier identification, and that they shouldn’t replace validated screening tools (Zubler et al., 2022).
What this means for you
- A CDC milestone is a reason to ask, not to wait. Each one is something at least 3 in 4 children already do by that age (CDC). If your child hasn’t reached one, talk to your child’s doctor and ask about developmental screening (CDC).
- Milestones don’t decide who needs help. ASHA says an SLP’s evaluation, not a milestone list, determines whether a child needs services (ASHA, 2022).
- Trust your instincts. ASHA says parents know their child best, and that there’s no downside to an evaluation if you’re worried: it either eases your mind or starts help early (ASHA, 2022).
How to act early
- Talk to your child’s doctor, share your concerns and ask about developmental screening (CDC).
- Ask about a hearing test: a speech-language evaluation often includes one (NIDCD).
- In the US, if your child is under 3, contact your state’s early intervention program yourself; a doctor’s referral isn’t needed. From 3, contact your local public school, even if your child doesn’t go there (CDC). Find your state’s program.
More on what to look for: late talker or speech delay? and how to get a free speech evaluation.
Questions parents ask
Did the CDC lower the milestones for speech?
The CDC says it didn’t lower standards. In 2022 it changed each milestone to a skill at least 75% of children show by that age, which moved some skills, like saying about 50 words, to a later checklist at 30 months.
How many words should a 2-year-old say according to the CDC?
The CDC’s 2-year checklist doesn’t give a word count: it lists putting at least two words together, like “more milk”. It places about 50 words at 30 months, while ASHA’s milestones put at least 50 words between 19 and 24 months.
Why did ASHA criticize the new CDC milestones?
ASHA wasn’t involved in the revision and worried that moving skills to older ages could encourage waiting and slow referrals. A 2023 review also found the evidence behind the CDC’s vocabulary milestones was conflicting or missing.
What was added in the 2022 CDC milestones update?
New checklists at 15 and 30 months, so every well-child visit from 2 months to 5 years has one, plus open-ended questions about parents’ concerns. Separate warning-sign lists were dropped because most became milestones.
My child meets the new CDC milestones but I’m still worried. Should I wait?
No. ASHA says there’s no downside to an evaluation if you’re concerned, and in the US you can contact early intervention directly, without a doctor’s referral, if your child is under 3.
Sources
- Zubler, J. M., Wiggins, L. D., Macias, M. M., et al. (2022). Evidence-informed milestones for developmental surveillance tools. Pediatrics, 149(3), e2021052138.
- McNeilly, L. G. (2022). Speech, language, and feeding of children birth to 5 years old and the use of developmental milestone checklists. ZERO TO THREE, 43(1), 66–69.
- CDC Learn the Signs. Act Early.: Milestones by 1 year.
- CDC Learn the Signs. Act Early.: Milestones by 15 months.
- CDC Learn the Signs. Act Early.: Developmental milestones (18 months, 2 years, 30 months).
- CDC Learn the Signs. Act Early.: Milestones by 3 years.
- ASHA (2022, February 21; updated March 11). ASHA statement on CDC’s updated developmental milestones (archived copy).
- ASHA (2022). Frequently asked questions: CDC and AAP developmental milestones updates (archived copy).
- ASHA: Communication milestones: 19 to 24 months.
- American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org: Language delays in toddlers.
- Roberts, M. Y., Sone, B. J., Jones, M. K., Standley, M., Conner, T., Lee, E. D., Norton, E. S., Roman, J., Speights, M., Young, R., & Weisleder, A. (2023). What the evidence does (and does not) show for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention child development milestones: An illustrative example using expressive vocabulary. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 66(9), 3622–3632.
- ASHA (2022). ASHA comments on CDC and AAP developmental milestones updates.
- ASHA: Creation of ASHA’s developmental milestones and references.
- Zubler, J., & Whitaker, T. (2022). CDC’s revised developmental milestone checklists. American Family Physician, 106(4), 370–371.
- National Institute on Deafness and Other Communication Disorders (NIH): Speech and language developmental milestones.
- CDC Learn the Signs. Act Early.: Early intervention.