For speech-language pathologists

Articulation word lists vs the words kids say most: what the data shows

Published · Updated

The short answer

In our own picture-based word lists, the problem wasn’t rare words but missing small ones. We checked 372 words from our articulation word lists and flash cards for S, R, L, K and TH against Wordbank’s parent-report data for 2½-year-olds and Dolch’s list of service words. Where the pictured words are on the 680-word toddler checklist, they’re well known: for S, R, L and K, a median of 86% to 91% of 2½-year-olds say them. But the S, R, L and K lists include just 11 of the 134 Dolch service words with those sounds, and none of the 25 with K. “Yes”, the most-said S word on the checklist (99%), isn’t on either S list, and “please” (98%) and “thank you” (98%) are missing from the L and K lists. TH was the exception, with 11 of 16. The case for adding these words is what children need every day, not a promise of faster progress.

Why we checked our own lists

A speech-language pathologist (SLP) we spoke with said articulation materials often use low-frequency words and ignore the order children develop in. Her example: there’s little point practicing “seal” if a child can’t say “so” or “said”. This page checks the first point: which words are on a list.

Our older free word lists were built around pictures. Their method note says the words are “early, concrete words that most children aged 4 to 8 can picture”, and every flash card needed a picture that clearly shows the word. Small words like yes, so and said can’t be drawn. So we counted what that format left out, using our own articulation word lists and flash card decks. We haven’t analyzed anyone else’s materials, and these numbers say nothing about them.

Finding 1: the small words are missing

Dolch’s service words are the non-noun words, such as said, so and soon, that Dolch found children meet most in books (Dolch, 1936). We used them as a marker of the small words children use all day. For each sound, we counted the Dolch words that contain it, and how many are on our picture lists and on our newer high-frequency lists.

Dolch service words that contain each sound, and how many are on each kind of list
SoundDolch words with the soundOn our picture listsOn our high-frequency listExamples missing from the picture lists (share of 2½-year-olds who say it)
S283 (saw, sleep, stop)25yes 99%, sit 92%, see 88%, some 78%, so 38%, said (not on the CDI)
R474 (around, four, red, run)37drink 94%, read 92%, here 83%, where 82%, for 63%, are 57%
L344 (blue, fly, light, yellow)28please 98%, play 95%, help 88%, look 87%, like 86%, all 74%
K25024cold 95%, walk 91%, look 87%, like 86%, can 72%, come (not on the CDI)
TH161116with 69%, then 34%, their 29%; three and together (not on the CDI)
S, R, L and K13411114

The 11 are generous to the picture lists: “saw” is pictured as the tool and “fly” as the insect. TH is the exception because our older TH list added voiced words such as the, this, they and there on purpose. It leaves out “three” on purpose too, because THR is a blend.

The same gap shows up among the most-said words on the toddler checklist. “Yes” is the most-said S word, “please” is tied for second among L words, and “thank you” is second among K words and first among TH words. Yet “yes” isn’t on our S picture lists, “please” isn’t on our L lists and “thank you” isn’t on our K lists.

Finding 2: the pictured words are familiar, where there’s data

We expected the picture lists to be full of rare words. Mostly they weren’t. For each sound, we looked up every picture-list word on the MacArthur-Bates Communicative Development Inventory (CDI): Words and Sentences, a 680-word checklist parents fill in, using Wordbank’s American English data for 30-month-olds (Frank et al., 2017; Frank et al., 2021).

Picture-list words on the CDI, and the median share of 2½-year-olds who say them
SoundPicture-list wordsOn the CDIMedian: picture-list wordsMedian: all CDI words with the soundMedian: our high-frequency listOf the 10 most-said CDI words with the sound, on the picture lists
S763688%80% (137 words)84%6
R1165490%81% (194 words)86%7 or 8 (four words tie for 10th)
L793986%81% (136 words)84%5
K482691%83% (136 words)87%6
TH531879%71% (25 words)73%9

So the pictured words that are on the CDI are said by more 2½-year-olds than the typical CDI word with the same sound, and by more than the words on our own high-frequency lists, which add small words toddlers say less often, such as so (38%) and us (34%). Most of the 10 most-said words with each sound are nouns, such as car, juice, ball and cookie, and the picture lists have 5 to 9 of them.

The other half is unknown. 199 of the 372 picture-list words (53%) aren’t on the CDI at all, including saxophone, faucet, flying saucer, llama, flamingo, koala, mammoth, panther and thermometer. The CDI gives no data for them either way: not being on a 680-word toddler checklist doesn’t make a word rare.

Five pairs that show the gap

How we counted

Limits

What this means for word lists

Pictures still earn their place: they work for children who can’t read yet, and the pictured nouns are mostly familiar. The gap is a missing row of small words. ASHA’s client-specific target selection includes relevance to the child and family, and in the core vocabulary approach the practice words are ones the child uses often in everyday life (ASHA). Gierut’s review recommends high-frequency words as treatment words, alongside late-acquired ones (Gierut, 2016).

Our free high-frequency lists put these words first, sorted by position and word shape, with each word’s CDI share and Dolch mark: S words, R words, L words, K words and TH words.

Questions SLPs ask

Do articulation word lists use too many rare words?

In our own picture-based lists, mostly not. The pictured words that are on the CDI are said by a median of 86% to 91% of 2½-year-olds for S, R, L and K. What’s missing is the small words: the lists include 11 of the 134 Dolch service words with those sounds.

What are high-frequency words in articulation therapy?

Words children say often in everyday life, such as yes, see, more, please, look and with. Many are small words that can’t be pictured, so picture-based lists tend to leave them out.

Do high-frequency words make articulation therapy faster?

Not reliably. Frequent words led to more generalization in one small study but had no clear effect on their own in a later one, and late-acquired words did better in another. The reason to include them is functional: children use them all day.

Why don’t picture word lists include words like yes and said?

Because they can’t be drawn. When every word needs a picture, lists fill with concrete nouns, and small everyday words drop out.

Where do the percentages come from?

From Wordbank’s American English data for the MacArthur-Bates CDI: Words and Sentences. Each is the share of 30-month-olds whose parents reported they say the word. Wordbank’s data is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license.

Sources

Join the Early Adopter Program