For speech-language pathologists
How do I plan a speech therapy group with mixed goals and ages?
Published · Updated
The short answer
Plan a mixed group around one shared activity, with each child working on their own target inside it. Group by compatible goals, grade and ability where the schedule allows, open with a short burst of individual practice for each child, build each target into the shared task, and take data on one or two goals per child. The evidence is limited: older trials found group and individual therapy did about equally well, but they grouped children with similar needs.
Grouping strategies
Mixed groups are usually a product of scheduling and caseload, not a clinical choice. ASHA notes that large caseloads may push school speech-language pathologists (SLPs) from individual to group treatment, and to bigger groups, when that isn’t ideal for the student (ASHA). In a survey of almost 2,000 school SLPs, students at both ends of the severity range were typically seen in groups outside the classroom, and the authors concluded that caseload size and years of practice appeared to shape those decisions (Brandel & Frome Loeb, 2011).
ASHA has no practice policy on group size. It names grade level, abilities, and the similarity or compatibility of IEP goals as grouping factors, and says placement should be based on each student’s needs (ASHA). Within those limits:
- Group by compatibility, not just diagnosis. A child working on /s/ in phrases and a child working on describing with adjectives can share a picture-description task. Two children who both need long runs of individual drill at very different levels are harder to combine.
- Keep the age gap workable. A kindergartner and a fifth grader rarely want the same game. If the schedule forces it, give the older child a role, such as scorekeeper or judge, alongside their own practice.
- Watch for children with several needs. In 670 school therapy sessions, children with a reported comorbidity received smaller doses of speech sound practice than children with a speech sound disorder alone (Farquharson et al., 2022). A child with both speech and language goals may need their speech practice protected.
- Review groups as children change. ASHA notes that group sizes vary and change over time, and that frequency, location and duration should be revisited as students progress (ASHA).
One shared activity, individual targets
The core move is a single activity that gives every child something to practice on every turn. Choose the activity for the language goals, which need content, then load the articulation targets into it. The table shows how one activity can carry different goals; it’s an illustration, not a tested protocol.
| Activity | Articulation goal (/s/ in phrases) | Articulation goal (/r/ in words) | Language goal (vocabulary or grammar) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Barrier game: describe a picture so a partner can draw it | Picture packed with /s/ words; says each as a phrase (“six socks”) | Names /r/ items before each turn (“rabbit”, “car”) | Uses two describing words or a spatial term per clue |
| Shared storybook | Retells a page using marked /s/ words | Reads or names /r/ words on each page | Answers who, what and why questions, or retells in order |
| Sorting cards into categories | Says each card in a carrier phrase (“I see ___”) | Says each /r/ card three times before placing it | Explains the category: “They go together because…” |
| Simple board game | Five /s/ productions before each move | Five /r/ productions before each move | Forms a sentence with a target verb or plural before moving |
Two habits make this work. Write each child’s target level on a card in front of you, so you don’t drift up or down the articulation hierarchy. And build the vocabulary list for the language student from words that contain the articulation students’ sounds, so their models double as practice.
Keeping practice trials high
Mixed groups are where trial counts fall fastest, because a language turn (a question, an explanation) takes far longer than a production. In 670 sessions reported by 90 school SLPs, each child’s dose of speech sound practice fell as group size rose (Farquharson et al., 2022). Small groups can still work: in a randomized study of 28 children aged 6 to 9, a motor-learning treatment that mixed words, sentences and storytelling in random order, given in groups of up to four, led children to acquire their target sounds within 40 half-hour sessions (d = 1.31) (Skelton & Richard, 2016).
The research on trial counts, drill play and group tactics is covered in practice trials per session. For mixed groups specifically:
- Front-load the speech practice. Give each articulation student a 1- to 2-minute burst of rapid productions at the start, while the others do a short independent task such as sorting their cards.
- Don’t let articulation students wait through language turns. Give them something to say during each language turn: a quick set of their own words, or judging whether a peer’s answer used the target word.
- Pair the language turn with a speech turn. “Tell us why these go together, then you say your five /s/ words.” Drill play, with quick trials before a motivating event, was at least as effective and efficient as plain drill in Shriberg and Kwiatkowski’s studies (Shriberg & Kwiatkowski, 1982).
- Count, don’t estimate. A tally per child shows quickly whether the language-heavy activity has squeezed out speech practice.
Taking data in a group
Decisions about whether treatment is working should generally rest on data, and Olswang and Bain separate treatment data on practiced items from generalization data on untreated probes (Olswang & Bain, 1994). In a group you can’t score everything, so decide in advance what you will score.
- One or two goals per child per session. Rotate goals across the week rather than scoring all of them every time.
- Different data for different goals. Speech sound goals suit trial-by-trial tallies (+, −, ~) with the cue level. Language goals often suit a count of opportunities and correct responses, or a short rubric for a retell.
- Probe on a schedule. Run a short untreated-word probe every few weeks for each speech goal, ideally at the start of a session before the group warms up.
- Record when you can’t listen closely. Scoring distortions live while running a group adds rater error. With consent, audio-record a probe and score it later. See how reliable speech sound ratings are.
Printable session, probe and progress sheets are in the speech therapy data sheets. For turning the numbers into reports, see speech therapy progress reports.
What the evidence says about groups
There’s little direct evidence, and none we found on mixed groups specifically. What exists comes from groups of children with similar needs:
- Speech sounds. A 2003 Cochrane review found one trial comparing group and individual therapy for phonology, with essentially no difference between them (standardized mean difference 0.01) (Law, Garrett & Nye, 2003). In that 1966 trial, children in grades 2 to 6 with mild or moderate difficulties were assigned to conditions by grade and severity and had about 40 minutes of therapy a week for 8.5 months (Sommers et al., 1966, as summarized by Law, Garrett & Nye, 2003). The reviewers cautioned that their group-versus-individual conclusion came mainly from phonological studies and may apply less to language (Law, Garrett & Nye, 2003).
- Language. In a Scottish trial of 161 children aged 6 to 11 with primary language impairment, therapy three times a week for 15 weeks improved expressive but not receptive language compared with usual care, and individual and group modes didn’t differ on the main outcomes (Boyle et al., 2009). Children with moderate or severe speech sound or fluency difficulties were excluded (Boyle et al., 2007).
- Service delivery. A systematic review of service delivery models for elementary students found only 5 studies that met its criteria, with some evidence that classroom-based services are at least as effective as pull-out for some goals. Lacking better evidence, the authors said clinicians must rely on reason-based practice and their own data (Cirrin et al., 2010).
So the research supports groups as a format, not mixed grouping as a choice. Your own probe data is the evidence that a particular mixed group is working. For the wider question of whether group therapy is enough, see group speech therapy and caseloads.
Sample session structures (illustrations)
These are illustrations of how a mixed session can be laid out, not tested protocols. Adjust timings to the children’s attention and goals.
| Minutes | What happens | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 0–3 | Each child says their goal for today; set out target cards | Children know what they’re practicing |
| 3–10 | Rapid individual bursts: each articulation student gets 2 to 3 minutes of drill while the others sort cards or prepare materials | Protects speech practice before the shared task |
| 10–25 | Shared activity with embedded targets (barrier game, book or board game), with several productions per turn | Language practice in context; speech trials continue |
| 25–28 | Quick probe or self-rating for one goal per child | Data you can act on |
| 28–30 | Send home this week’s words or task | Practice continues between sessions |
Other layouts to try. Stations: if you have a second adult, run one station for rapid articulation drill and one for a language task, and switch halfway. Theme across the week: keep one book or topic for a week, so language goals build on the content while articulation targets come from its vocabulary. Split by goal type: if one child’s speech goal needs intensive cueing, see that child for a few minutes alone at the start or end and run the group for the rest.
For larger caseload strategies, see managing a large caseload, and for sending practice home, speech home practice programs.
Questions SLPs ask
How do you run a mixed speech and language therapy group?
Choose one activity that serves the language goals, load the articulation targets into it, and give each speech student a short burst of individual practice. Score one or two goals per child each session.
How many students should be in a speech therapy group?
ASHA has no practice policy on group size, though some states give guidance. Research shows each child gets fewer speech sound trials as group size rises, so smaller groups protect practice.
Is group speech therapy as effective as individual therapy?
The few trials that compared them found similar results, both for speech sounds and for language. Those studies grouped children with similar needs, so they don’t show how mixed groups compare.
How do I take data in a group speech therapy session?
Decide in advance which goal you’ll score for each child, use quick tallies for speech sounds and opportunity counts for language, and run untreated-word probes every few weeks.
Sources
- ASHA Practice Portal: Caseload and workload.
- Brandel, J., & Frome Loeb, D. (2011). Program intensity and service delivery models in the schools: SLP survey results. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 42(4), 461–490.
- ASHA: School-based service delivery in speech-language pathology.
- Farquharson, K., McIlraith, A., Tambyraja, S., & Constantino, C. (2022). Using the experience sampling method to examine the details of dosage in school-based speech sound therapy. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 53(3), 698–712.
- Skelton, S. L., & Richard, J. T. (2016). Application of a motor learning treatment for speech sound disorders in small groups. Perceptual and Motor Skills, 122(3), 840–854.
- Shriberg, L. D., & Kwiatkowski, J. (1982). Phonological disorders II: A conceptual framework for management. Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders, 47(3), 242–256.
- Olswang, L. B., & Bain, B. (1994). Data collection: Monitoring children’s treatment progress. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology, 3(3), 55–66.
- Law, J., Garrett, Z., & Nye, C. (2003). Speech and language therapy interventions for children with primary speech and language delay or disorder. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, (3), CD004110.
- Sommers, R. K., Schaeffer, M. H., Leiss, R. H., Gerber, A. J., Bray, M. A., Fundrella, D., Olson, J. K., & Tomkins, E. R. (1966). The effectiveness of group and individual therapy. Journal of Speech and Hearing Research, 9(2), 219–225.
- Boyle, J. M., McCartney, E., O’Hare, A., & Forbes, J. (2009). Direct versus indirect and individual versus group modes of language therapy for children with primary language impairment: Principal outcomes from a randomized controlled trial and economic evaluation. International Journal of Language & Communication Disorders, 44(6), 826–846.
- Boyle, J., McCartney, E., Forbes, J., & O’Hare, A. (2007). A randomised controlled trial and economic evaluation of direct versus indirect and individual versus group modes of speech and language therapy for children with primary language impairment. Health Technology Assessment, 11(25), 1–139.
- Cirrin, F. M., Schooling, T. L., Nelson, N. W., et al. (2010). Evidence-based systematic review: Effects of different service delivery models on communication outcomes for elementary school-age children. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 41(3), 233–264.