For speech-language pathologists

How should SLPs evaluate speech therapy apps, AI and other technology?

Published · Updated

The short answer

Judge speech therapy technology the way you would any treatment. Ask for published evidence in children like yours, accuracy on children’s error productions rather than overall, and a clear account of what it records and keeps. Then check the privacy law that applies (in the US, HIPAA and a business associate agreement in health care, FERPA in schools, COPPA for children under 13), accessibility, cost, and whether it fits the treatment plan. ASHA says efficacy claims for AI tools must be backed by evidence.

Evidence: tested on whom, and by whom?

ASHA defines evidence-based practice as bringing together clinical expertise, the best available evidence, and the client’s and caregivers’ perspectives (ASHA). Its guidance on evaluating products asks clinicians to use a product with populations for which there are accuracy data, ideally reflecting the racial, ethnic and linguistic diversity of the people they serve. Without validity data, you need to be able to justify using it and note the limits (ASHA). For AI tools, ASHA says “any claims about the efficacy of an AI tool must be substantiated with evidence” (ASHA).

For what’s being studied in AI and wearables, see AI and wearables in speech therapy. For teletherapy evidence, see online speech therapy for kids.

Accuracy with children’s speech

An overall accuracy figure can hide the number that matters. In a systematic review of 32 studies and 18 automated speech analysis tools, tools met an 80% agreement threshold with human judges for intelligibility, severity or error category, but accuracy was typically below 80% on words containing mispronunciations (McKechnie et al., 2018). Speech recognition is also significantly less accurate for children than for adults, partly because there’s far less child speech data to train on (Shivakumar & Georgiou, 2020).

A 2025 tutorial gives clinicians a framework for appraising clinical AI for validity, reliability, and ethical and equitable use (Benway & Preston, 2025). More in automated speech scoring for SLPs.

Privacy in health care: HIPAA and business associate agreements

In the US, if you or your practice is a HIPAA covered entity, a vendor that creates, receives, maintains or transmits protected health information (PHI) for you is generally a business associate, and HIPAA requires a business associate agreement (BAA) before you share PHI with it. HHS’s examples include a cloud service that stores electronic PHI, an app vendor that provides transcription services, and a third-party AI chatbot on a patient portal (HHS).

The BAA has to describe how the vendor may use and disclose PHI and bar other uses. The Security Rule also requires the vendor to report security incidents, including breaches, and the vendor needs BAAs with any subcontractors that handle the PHI (HHS).

In schools: FERPA, and COPPA for children under 13

In most cases, HIPAA’s Privacy Rule doesn’t apply to an elementary or secondary school. Student health records at a FERPA-covered school, including those kept by a contracted provider acting for the school, are education records under FERPA instead. Even where HIPAA doesn’t apply, FERPA and IDEA require written parental consent before a school shares a student’s information with Medicaid for billing (US Department of Education [ED] & HHS, 2019).

More on COPPA in children’s voice data privacy. This is general information, not legal advice: check with your district, employer or a lawyer for your situation.

Accessibility, cost and fit with the treatment plan

Disclosure

Saylo, which publishes this page, is a speech-practice wearable in development. It hasn’t been tested with children yet, and we’ll publish validation results before making any claims about accuracy or outcomes.

Questions SLPs ask

Do I need a BAA with a speech therapy app?

If you’re a HIPAA covered entity and the app creates, receives, maintains or transmits PHI for you, it’s generally a business associate and you need a BAA. Check with your compliance team or a lawyer about your situation.

Does HIPAA apply to school-based SLPs?

Usually not to student records. In most cases, health records at a FERPA-covered school are education records under FERPA, so FERPA’s rules on consent and vendors apply instead.

Can a school consent to an app collecting a child’s voice under COPPA?

Only in limited cases. The FTC says a school can consent for parents when data is collected for the school’s use and benefit and for no other commercial purpose.

What accuracy figure should I look for?

There’s no single threshold. Ask for agreement with several SLP raters on children’s error productions specifically, in children like the ones you treat, because overall figures can hide weak performance on mispronounced words.

Sources

Join the Early Adopter Program