For speech-language pathologists
How does consent work when children’s speech is recorded for research or AI?
Published · Updated
The short answer
In US research covered by federal human-subjects rules, a child takes part only with a parent’s permission and, when the child is able, the child’s own assent, under procedures approved by an institutional review board (IRB). Assent means active agreement: not objecting isn’t enough, and a capable child’s “no” generally prevails. Families should be told how recordings will be stored, shared and reused. Voices are hard to make anonymous, so it’s worth asking whether recordings could train AI and what happens on withdrawal.
Which rules apply
- The Common Rule applies to human subjects research conducted, supported or otherwise regulated by a federal agency that has adopted it (45 CFR 46.101). Research outside that scope, such as some privately funded product development, may not be covered by it.
- Subpart D adds protections for children, defined as people who haven’t reached the legal age to consent to the research procedures where the research takes place (45 CFR 46.402). For research with no more than minimal risk, the IRB must find adequate provisions for children’s assent and parents’ permission (45 CFR 46.404), and one parent’s permission may be enough (45 CFR 46.408).
- Fewer exemptions. For children, survey and interview research, and observation where the researchers take part, can’t use one of the exemptions that’s available for the same kinds of research with adults (OHRP).
- COPPA, the US children’s online privacy law, can also apply when an online service collects data from children under 13. It treats an audio file of a child’s voice as personal information, and sharing a child’s data with third parties to train or develop AI isn’t integral to a service and needs separate parental consent (FTC, 2025).
- ASHA’s Code of Ethics says SLPs may include people in research only when participation is voluntary, without coercion and with informed consent, and must protect the confidentiality of research participants (ASHA, 2023).
Parental permission and child assent
Permission is a parent’s or guardian’s agreement to their child taking part. Assent is the child’s affirmative agreement, and mere failure to object shouldn’t be taken as assent (45 CFR 46.402). In OHRP’s words, the child must actively show willingness rather than just comply (OHRP).
The IRB decides whether children can assent, considering their ages, maturity and psychological state. It can make that judgment for the whole study or child by child, and assent isn’t required if a child’s capability is too limited to consult them (45 CFR 46.408). The American Academy of Pediatrics describes permission and assent as an active process, with children’s opinions included more as they mature (Katz et al., 2016).
- For young children, OHRP suggests focusing on an accurate picture of what taking part will be like: what will happen, how long it will take, and whether there’s any discomfort (OHRP).
- Documentation of assent isn’t required by the HHS rules. The IRB decides; for children who can’t yet read, it should be in a form that records that assent took place (OHRP).
- Disagreement. If a child who can assent says no, the child’s decision prevails even if the parents agreed, unless the IRB waived assent because the research offers an important direct benefit available only in the study (OHRP).
- Growing up. When a child reaches the legal age of consent during a study, researchers should get the now-adult’s own consent for ongoing participation, including continued analysis of identifiable data, unless the IRB waives it (OHRP).
In practice, for a recording task with a young child, that can mean showing the microphone, explaining in a sentence what they’ll say and for how long, and treating reluctance or wanting to stop as a no.
Telling families how recordings are stored, shared and destroyed
The consent process must describe how far records identifying the participant will be kept confidential, and must say either that identifiers might be removed and the information used in future research without further consent, or that it won’t be used that way even with identifiers removed (45 CFR 46.116).
If researchers ask for broad consent to store and reuse identifiable data, they must describe the types of research it may be used for, what information may be used and shared, the kinds of institutions that might use it, and how long it may be kept, which can be indefinitely (45 CFR 46.116).
ASHA’s ethics guidance lists precautions such as storing research records securely, limiting access, removing or coding identifying information, and getting written consent from a parent before sharing findings that include video or audio recordings that might identify a child (ASHA).
Why voices are hard to de-identify
A voice is an identifier in its own right. HIPAA’s de-identification standard lists voice prints and full-face photographs among the identifiers that must be removed (45 CFR 164.514), and the updated COPPA Rule counts voiceprints as biometric identifiers (FTC, 2025). Speech recordings can be used for purposes ranging from health profiling to recognizing who is speaking (Nautsch et al., 2019).
Tools that disguise voices are still being tested. In a 2025 challenge, the best attack systems cut the error rate for matching anonymized speech to the right speaker by 25 to 44%, relative to the standard test attacker (Tomashenko et al., 2025). Disguising a voice doesn’t guarantee it can’t be linked back. Recordings can also contain names, schools or other details said aloud.
This matters because research rules allow de-identified data to be reused without new consent if the consent form said so (45 CFR 46.116). Ask exactly what “de-identified” will mean for audio.
Withdrawal, secondary use and AI training
- Withdrawal. Participation must be voluntary, and a participant can stop at any time without penalty (45 CFR 46.116).
- Data already collected. OHRP’s guidance says that when someone withdraws, researchers may keep and analyze data already collected, even if it’s identifiable. Researchers can choose to honor a request to destroy or exclude the data, and OHRP recommends explaining at consent whether data will be kept after withdrawal (OHRP, 2010).
- Secondary use. Future research use depends on what the consent form said about removing identifiers, or on broad consent (45 CFR 46.116).
- AI training. Under COPPA, sharing a child’s data with third parties to train AI needs separate parental consent (FTC, 2025). In 2023 the FTC and Department of Justice alleged that Amazon kept children’s Alexa voice recordings indefinitely and used them to improve its speech recognition; Amazon agreed to a $25 million civil penalty (FTC, 2023).
Questions parents can ask before saying yes
- Has an IRB reviewed this study, and who can I contact with questions about my child’s rights?
- What will my child be asked to do, for how long, and will you ask them too?
- Is it audio or video, and where will the recordings be stored? Who can access them?
- Will recordings be shared with other researchers or companies, and in what form?
- Could recordings, or anything made from them, be used to train AI, now or later?
- What does “de-identified” mean for my child’s voice?
- How long will recordings be kept, and when will they be destroyed?
- If we withdraw, will you delete recordings already collected? What about any that have already been used?
For SLPs: if you collect recordings for a study or a product, or help recruit families, check with an IRB before you start. For apps and devices that record children outside research, see children’s voice data privacy.
This is general information, not legal advice.
Disclosure
Saylo, which publishes this page, is a speech-practice wearable in development. It hasn’t been tested with children yet. How Saylo plans to keep any research separate and consented is on its privacy and safety page.
Questions SLPs ask
Can a child refuse to take part in research if their parent agreed?
Yes, generally. If the IRB requires assent and the child is able to give it, the child’s “no” prevails, except in rare studies offering an important direct benefit available only through the research.
Does my child have to sign a consent form?
Not necessarily. US federal rules don’t require written assent; the IRB decides how assent is recorded, and for young children who can’t read it may simply be noted.
Can I withdraw my child’s recordings from a study?
Your child can stop taking part at any time. Under OHRP guidance, researchers may keep data already collected but can choose to delete it, so ask before you agree.
Can research recordings of children be used to train AI?
It depends on what the consent form says. De-identified data may be reused without new consent if families were told, and online services covered by COPPA need separate parental consent to share children’s data for AI training.
Is an anonymized voice recording really anonymous?
Not always. Voice prints count as identifiers under HIPAA, and research on voice anonymization shows stronger attacks can partly undo it.
Sources
- Common Rule, 45 CFR 46.101: To what does this policy apply?
- 45 CFR part 46, subpart D: Additional protections for children involved as subjects in research (46.401–46.409).
- HHS Office for Human Research Protections: Research with children FAQs.
- Federal Trade Commission (2025). Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule: Final rule. Federal Register 90(76), 16918–16983 (April 22, 2025).
- ASHA (2023). Code of ethics (effective March 1, 2023).
- Katz, A. L., Webb, S. A., & Committee on Bioethics. (2016). Informed consent in decision-making in pediatric practice. Pediatrics, 138(2), e20161485.
- Common Rule, 45 CFR 46.116: General requirements for informed consent.
- ASHA: Issues in ethics: Confidentiality.
- HIPAA, 45 CFR 164.514(b): De-identification of protected health information.
- Nautsch, A., Jiménez, A., Treiber, A., Kolberg, J., Jasserand, C., Kindt, E., Delgado, H., Todisco, M., Hmani, M. A., Mtibaa, A., Abdelraheem, M. A., Abad, A., Teixeira, F., Matrouf, D., Gomez-Barrero, M., Petrovska-Delacrétaz, D., Chollet, G., Evans, N., Schneider, T., … Busch, C. (2019). Preserving privacy in speaker and speech characterisation. Computer Speech & Language, 58, 441–480.
- Tomashenko, N., Miao, X., Vincent, E., & Yamagishi, J. (2025). The First VoicePrivacy Attacker Challenge. ICASSP 2025: IEEE International Conference on Acoustics, Speech and Signal Processing, 1–2.
- HHS Office for Human Research Protections (2010). Guidance on withdrawal of subjects from research: Data retention and other related issues.
- Federal Trade Commission (2023). FTC and DOJ charge Amazon with violating children’s privacy law by keeping kids’ Alexa voice recordings forever (press release, May 31, 2023).